Atzei Rimon Blog

← ALL ARTICLES

Are Monsters Born or Made? Literary parallels of Eisav, his character, and his fate

Is Eisav really evil or is he a product of his environment? We take a look at his character and the literary archetype he inspired through the ages.

Jacob and Esau, Shraga Weil, 1956.

For those who were raised within a Jewish religious framework, we grow up with a very clear idea of Eisav as a wicked character; in contrast to our forefather Yacov who is the personification of goodness, Eisav is widely regarded as the personification of wickedness.

But for someone who is new to the Torah and reading these stories for the first time, we come across an interesting perspective. When the words of the Torah are read at surface level just with the narrative of the story on the page, we do not actually see much evidence of Eisav’s supposed and well-known wickedness. A new reader to the Torah might actually feel quite sorry for Eisav. Look at the basic narrative: he is born red and hairy, his mother doesn’t love him, his brother tricks him out of his birthright in exchange for food when he is starving, and everyone hates his wife. Then, as his father lies dying, he doesn’t recognise him and gives his birthright blessing to someone else. And then his distant cousin Leah apparently cries for weeks at the mere idea of having to marry him? And then his head gets chopped off! It certainly doesn’t seem like Eisav was given a fair chance.

It is only when we read further into the Torah and examine the commentaries and midrash that we see why Eisav is regarded as such a wicked character and see the truth of the terrible crimes he committed. But nonetheless, the question can remain for many: was Eisav inherently evil and wicked, did he choose wickedness on his own accord, or was he born into the role of “wicked son” and simply never stood a chance?

Isaac and Jacob, Norman Lindsay, 2013.

וַיֶּאֱהַב יִצְחָק אֶת־עֵשָׂו ... וְרִבְקָה אֹהֶבֶת אֶת־יַעֲקֹב
“Isaac loved Esau ... but Rebecca loved Jacob.”
— Bereishit 25:28

It is inferred from this line that Rivka did not love Eisav, or perhaps simply did not love him as much as she loved Yacov. Was that because of Eisav’s inherent wickedness? Or did she fear his portended wickedness and pull away from him, to the point where his character development did not achieve its full potential? Thus begins the timeless literary struggle: are villains born or made?

וַיִּתְרֹצְצוּ הַבָּנִים בְּקִרְבָּהּ
“The children struggled within her.”
— Bereishit 25:22

Rivka is given a prophecy while she is still pregnant with the brothers that they will be at war and the progenitors of warring kingdoms. Is it her fear of this prophecy that leads her to love one son and potentially neglect another? Is it this treatment that pushes Eisav down his path of wickedness, or did she simply see the inevitability of this path, and do what she could to protect Yacov and the destiny of the Jewish people, his descendants?

Indeed, Rav Hirsch on his commentary on Bereishit 25:27 raises this very question:

“Had Isaac and Rebecca studied Esau’s nature and character early enough, and asked themselves how can even an Esau, how can all the strength and energy, agility and courage that lies slumbering in this child, be won over to be used in the service of God, and the future גבר be trained to become, not a גבר ציד, but in truth a גבר לפני ה׳, then Jacob and Esau, with their totally different natures, could still have remained twin-brothers in spirit and life; quite early in life Esau’s “sword” and Jacob’s “spirit” could have worked hand in hand, and who can say what a different aspect the whole history of the ages might have presented.”

חֲנֹךְ לַנַּעַר עַל פִּי דַרְכּוֹ
“Educate a child according to his way.”
— Mishlei 22:6

This question and character concept is one that we see time and time again in literature throughout the ages. Are monsters born or made? Are people born inherently good or bad, and if so, where does free will come into play? If a person’s wickedness comes down to the intent of their choices, are their deeds still punishable if they were well-meaning but ill-fated decisions? And perhaps most importantly, if a person’s nature and choices is shaped by their life experience, circumstances and/or a lack of parental guidance, how much of the blame really lies on them?

Heathcliff Under the Tree, Fritz Eichenberg, 1943

Heathcliff: Eisav of the moors

When Yacov and Eisav grow up and display their unique personalities, Eisav is described as a man of the field, who loves hunting, whereas Yacov is a “wholesome man who dwelled in tents”. Yes, one might say that a natural hunter might have a propensity towards violence or harshness, but we could also say that about King David, who had great success in battle, and while the blood on his hands was not without consequence, he is certainly not considered an evil figure of our history. 

One interesting literary figure that springs to mind is Emily Bronte’s Heathcliff in Wuthering Heights. Heathcliff, who is adopted as an orphan and initially raised in comfort, is later forced to abandon his education and work in the fields for his adopted siblings. Heathcliff’s wildness, brooding nature and bitter need for vengeance are all key parts of his character – but was he created a monster, or was the monster created within him by the forces around and the circumstances of his life?

Boris Karloff as Frankenstein's monster in the movide adaptation Bride of Frankenstein (1935)

“I was benevolent and good; misery made me a fiend.”

Perhaps the archetypal example of a man-made monster is from Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein. Indeed, Frankenstein’s monster has become so well-known and much of a pop culture figure as, well, a monster! It’s so ironic considering that in the original novel he in fact was not a monster, but a kind, if gruesome-looking creature. It is only the horror with which the entire world regards him, that pushes him further and further into isolation, despair, and eventual descent into his final monstrousness.

Literary Eisavs can be discovered in literature throughout the ages, from Edmund in Shakespeare’s King Lear to Boo Radley in Harper Lee’s To Kill a Mockingbird. The question of how does one become an Eisav seems to take various literary paths – either one is simply born with a propensity for evil, or is it borne out of neglect or abuse, or from resentment at a sibling rivalry or widely perceived inferiority.

וְרַב יַעֲבֹד צָעִיר
“And the older shall serve the younger.”
— Bereishit 25:23

John Cazale and Al Pacino as Fredo and Michael in The Godfather: Part II

Mario Puzo’s The Godfather spreads out the Eisav-Yacov contrast across three brothers: Sonny, Fredo, and Michael. Sonny at first glance appears to be the Eisav – the oldest brother, naturally his father’s would-be successor, except he is too hot-headed and wild for his father to trust him with his birthright. Devoted to his parents and family, his wild and at times bloodthirsty nature leads to his undoing, and his younger brother taking up the family mantle in his place. But then comes another Eisav, Fredo. Fredo is the Eisav in that he is the older brother to Michael but has none of his grace, abilities or the favour of his parents. In his resentment of his inferiority to his younger brother, he betrays Michael, to the point of endangering his life. We see Michael first mourn the death of Sonny, the perhaps “lovable” side of Eisav, and then we see Michael actually order the death of Fredo, the despicable Eisav. And in turn, Michael himself now assumes an Eisav role, as he has now become the dangerous and bloodthirsty one.

The gifts we're given

It is a very Jewish concept that each of us is created perfectly and just as God intended; even our seeming weaknesses or character defects are in fact gifts created precisely for us. Each challenge is an opportunity for us to perfect ourselves and turn that one-time weakness into a strength. For example, one who struggles with self-esteem can grow into a compassionate and understanding mentor for young people and nurture confidence in others. Someone who has a tendency towards impatience can take an organizational job in a fast-paced company where keeping people punctual and on their toes is a much-needed asset. 

So again we come to the question, what might have happened if Eisav's physical energy, love of nature and courage had been nurtured as strengths, rather than being measured against Yacov's temperament?

The point of no return

Jacob and Esau, George Frederick Watts, 2014.

While we can theorise about Eisav’s pain and sadness and the reasons he turned out the way he did, we can’t forget that according to the Midrash and commentaries, he did commit some very serious and evil acts.

Though what we see in pshat generally only hints to his character, we do see a deeper look at a bloodthirstiness when he commits to killing his own brother. Now, we may say that this is borne out of neglect, betrayal, emotional wounds etc – but pointing to a cause of a certain behaviour doesn’t excuse the behaviour. Eisav is still a man with free will who chooses to go down the path of murder, or at least threatening murder.

וַיֹּאמֶר עֵשָׂו בְּלִבּוֹ ... וְאַהַרְגָה אֶת־יַעֲקֹב אָחִי
“Esau said to himself ... I will kill my brother Jacob.”
— Bereishit 27:41

This is unambiguous evidence of murderous intent in the straightforward narrative. However, was this the result of an innate murderous nature? Or the result of neglect and being told repeatedly that you are evil? Also, we don’t know just from this pshat whether Eisav actually intends to kill Yacov or if he is just uttering a rageful statement he will regret later. However, the Gemara seems to end this uncertainty as follows:

“You have nobody to love you; and, however miserable you make us, we shall still have the revenge of thinking that your cruelty arises from your greater misery.”
Catherine to Heathcliff in Wuthering Heights

Isaac and Esau, Adam Friedrich Oeser, 1717.

In Bava Batra 16B, Rabbi Yochanan brings down that Eisav committed a number of atrocities on the very day Avraham died, most notably rape, murder and heresy. Similarly, Shelley’s Frankenstein, who we pity for his neglect and lamentable fate, does later murder innocent people. No matter how sympathetic we may be to a person’s plight, certain deeds do cross a line into true evil actions whether or not we can understand how they got there. 

A tortured heart

We also learn that Eisav isn’t totally devoid of good qualities – perhaps even his goodnesses are channeled in heinous ways, but nonetheless, we do see that his skill with hunting brings him affection from his father, and his own devotion and honour towards his father is what merits him to have at least his head (!) buried in the Cave of the Patriarchs. 

“I don’t want anything to happen to him while my mother is alive.”
Michael Corleone ordering his brother Fredo’s death in the movie adaptation of Mario Puzo’s The Godfather.

Rashi on Bereishit 27:41 explains that Eisav intends to kill Yacov, but he will wait until after Yitzhak has died, so as not to cause his father any pain. We can also see in the pshat how greatly pained Eisav is when he is denied his father’s blessing. Similarly, when Yacov and Eisav are finally reunited, he seems to exhibit genuine emotion and love towards his brother.

וַיָּרָץ עֵשָׂו לִקְרָאתוֹ וַיְחַבְּקֵהוּ וַיִּפֹּל עַל־צַוָּארָו וַיִּשָּׁקֵהוּ וַיִּבְכּוּ
“Esau ran to meet him, embraced him, fell upon his neck, kissed him, and they wept.”
— Bereishit 33:4

The question now before us is: is the ability to love compatible with being cruel to others? Eisav's love and devotion for his father complicates the image of a man entirely devoid of feeling.

Misplaced compassion is not just a simple mistake, but can be dangerous and have far-reaching deadly consequences.

The limits of compassion 

It is made very clear in Judaism that there are serious limits on the compassion or sympathy we should allow ourselves to hold for villains. The midrash teaches that misplaced compassion towards the wicked can become cruelty towards the innocent. Judaism is not a religion of vengeance, but nor is it a “turn-the-other-cheek” approach. The Jewish way has serious consequences for one’s actions, responsibility to hold others accountable, and establish functioning courts of law. 

כל המרחם על האכזרים סופו להתאכזר על הרחמנים
“Whoever is merciful to the cruel will eventually be cruel to the merciful.”
Midrash — Tanchuma, Metzora 1

Similarly, though we can explain Eisav’s actions as the result of grief, resentment or neglect, this doesn’t negate a: the evilness of evil deeds or b: his own agency in choosing those actions. We can all sympathise with painful upbringings, but not everyone who grows up in the shadow of a sibling comes to think murderously towards them. Could Eisav have chosen differently? Or was it simply in his nature? If it was really indelibly in his nature, how much free choice did he really have?

אֵיזֶהוּ גִבּוֹר? הַכּוֹבֵשׁ אֶת יִצְרוֹ
“Who is mighty? One who conquers his inclination.”
Pirkei Avot 4:1

רְשׁוּת לְכָל אָדָם נְתוּנָה
“Free will is granted to every person.”
Rambam, Hilchot Teshuvah 5:1

This is where we come back to the concepts of our personal challenges being in fact gifts for our service of Hashem. Even someone like Eisav, who by many accounts had a harsh start in life, arguably overlooked by his parents, lacking in the dignity and poise of his brother, was born with the ability to transcend his challenges. Judaism teaches us that our hardships and character defects are part of us by design; therefore we have it in us the ability and the choice to transform such challenges into opportunities to serve Hashem. 

Eisav perhaps grew up feeling inferior to Yacov, but he could have challenged that to become a generational leader in practicing humility, being grateful to be in the witness of such greatness of his younger brother and overcoming his natural inclination to be perceived as great himself. Eisav perhaps felt that his parents overlooked him in favour of their younger son, but he could have turned this pain into his own parenting approach, having many children and showering them equally with love and opportunity. Eisav was naturally a hunter and enjoyed being out in the field, but he could have channeled his physical strength and mastery of animals into raising livestock for korbanot or becoming a shochet. 

The Meeting of Esau and Jacob, James Tisso, 1896.

“A person should not entertain the thesis held by the fools among the gentiles and the majority of the undeveloped among Israel that, at the time of a man's creation, The Holy One, blessed be He, decrees whether he will be righteous or wicked.”
Rambam, Mishneh Torah, Hilchot Teshuva 5:2.

Going back to Rav Hirsch’s commentary, we can see his concept now in a new angle. 

“Jacob and Esau, with their totally different natures could still have remained twin-brothers in spirit and life… Esau’s “sword” and Jacob’s “spirit” could have worked hand in hand.”

Yes, the possibility remains that if Yitzhak and Rivka had approached their sons’ differences in a better way, Eisav’s nature could have been channeled more positively and towards goodness. However, this doesn’t make Eisav’s actions any less wicked or absolve him from any accountability.

We may be able to say that the story of Eisav is indeed nuanced and tragic, view his story as a loss of potential and grieve for what might have been. But it is also an important lesson for all of us that no matter what our upbringing or circumstances, it is up to no one other than ourselves – our own unique opportunity and responsibility – to decide what we make of them in life.